Calculated Risk, and the limits of precaution


Soap Box:
There are practical limits to safety. I know this runs counter to everything you have been told, but it is true. Take the case of passenger jet flight, if they truly were interested in safety it would seem that rather than providing you a seat cushion that floats, they would provide a PARACHUTE Duhh...

They go even farther than that, try to smuggle a parachute on board a passenger flight and see what happens when you go through X-ray, they just don't seen to understand. In truth although most of us at first brush would think that a parachute would be a reasonable precaution, even if you could get to the door of a plane, jumping out of a plane traveling half the speed of sound would flatten you like a bug against the tail section, probably further damaging the plane, insuring even less control of an already crippled aircraft.

People who use parachutes, and survive their first use, have received a lot of training on how to exit the plane, and what to do after they are out. Then there is the logistical problem of being the only person on the doomed plane, with a parachute, standing at the door waiting for the proper time to exit the plane. By the time you are ready to do so, you will have picked up several hundred pounds of added weight in the form of frightened passengers. Finally passenger jets are not designed to jump out of, nor have procedures been written that pilots would have to be trained to execute in the event of a mishap, that would allow passengers to depart such a crippled plane while in flight. Parachutes are an example of a safety precaution that actually increases the risk to passengers.

In my heart of hearts, I honestly believe I will save more lives, than I kill. Writing a book, the author has to wait for the next edition to print revised safety information, a web page offers me an opportunity they simply cannot ever attain. I can make revisions as soon as an error comes to light. I assure you that safety information, tempered by the reality that I want the web page to actually teach electronics, will be given proper attention. The risk is still, and will always be yours, I cannot be responsible for your mistakes, and I will not cater to every "goodie two shoes" self appointed safety expert that would make any kind of experiment involving electricity impossible. They will kill more people than I do, by preventing information about reasonable safety precautions from reaching the hands of fledgling electrical engineers. To paint with the broad brush of just say no never worked, and never will. Sooner or later those who are curious, will always experiment, this is simply human nature, by providing factual, and reasoned, guidelines, that still allow the experiment to be performed, I not only teach electronics, but I save more lives than I kill.


back to lesson 014

The large print Giveth, and the small print Taketh away

CopyLeft License
Copyright © 2000 Jim Phillips

Know then: You have certain rights to the source data,
and distribution there of, under a CopyLeft License